Repair or Replace? Compare the Cost of the Years You Are Buying
A broken appliance creates an unfair contest. The repair quote is money due now for something already sitting in the house, while the replacement price seems to buy a clean slate. The useful comparison is not old versus new. It is the cost, disruption, and uncertainty attached to the next stretch of useful service.
That shift matters because a $500 repair is not automatically foolish on an older machine, and a $1,200 replacement is not automatically prudent because it has a warranty. The repair may buy several ordinary years. The replacement may require delivery, installation, new connections, disposal, financing, or changes to surrounding cabinets. Both choices buy time, and both can create costs beyond the first number on the page.
The worksheet below is meant for a non-emergency decision after safety has been addressed. If there is smoke, leaking gas, damaged wiring, flooding, structural danger, or another immediate hazard, stop using the equipment and follow qualified safety guidance. Cost comparison comes after people and property are protected.
Ask for the failed part, the work required, and what the diagnosis does not cover. A machine can be old with one isolated, repairable problem. It can also be fairly new with a failure that signals wider damage. Calendar age is useful context, but the condition of the major systems and the availability of parts do more work in the decision.